Now for the surprising dark horse:
SEPHORA's KAT VON D Lock-It Tattoo Concealer
I visited Sephora and asked one of the makeup artists, (Irwin, God Bless him!) to recommend a long wearing, high coverage concealer that doesn't cake or crease. He pointed to their house brand, Kat Von D and painted a bit on with his niffty little concealer brush. When I compared it to the NARS Radiant Creamy side, the Kat covered better and brightened my under-eye area noticeably without looking owlish. Bingo! So I purchased BOTH and will be testing them out under various conditions with my airbrush makeup which is bullet-proof but fantastic for coverage: Kett Cosmetics of NYC